Total Pageviews

Tuesday, May 3, 2011

Great Books Review

Six members met last night to discuss David Denby's "Great Books: My Adventures with Homer, Rousseau, Woolf, and the Other Indestructible Writers of the Western World."  The book's sponsor began by holding up Denby's two subsequent books--"American Sucker," in which Denby tries to make a killing in the stock market and gets clobbered and "Snark," which is about the low level of civic discourse.  Denby puts enough of his own story into his writing that "American Sucker," in particular, feels like a sequel to "Great Books."

We were fortunate that one of our group had done six years of graduate work and college teaching in philosophy.  She relished Denby's book and deepened our appreciation for it.  Another member, recently returned from Ethiopia, found that the Old Testament chapter reminded her of a way of life that still exists today.  

The rather small turnout and the fact that only half of those present finished the book suggests that it was a bit long and weighty for our group. 

Five out of six members felt,  however, that these classics are still relevant for today's college students.

Guest blogger:  BB

Overheard at a party celebrating a new pair of knees:
 If you are going to read any chapter read the chapter on  Shakespeare.   Denby writes about parallels between his mom and the character King Lear and reveals some memoir-like insights on his parents' influence on his life.

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

The World Below Review

During an early spring storm that brought lightning and icy streets,  the book group members met in a cozy warm room to  discuss The World Below.  The novel, which felt like a collection of short stories or a  "story-boarded" "potboiler" had illogical gaps for many of the group.  Why, for example, didn't the mental illness of the woman who linked the two main characters--Georgia and Cath--play a more dominant role in the characters' narratives? After all such a devastating illness would have had a major impact on the mother and the daughter of the victim.

The sections of the book that took place in Georgia's life up to and including the T.B. sanatorium were the most popular.  The theme--that there is a world below contained inside each of us resonated with one member--reading a book about an immigrant's life  helped her uncover the world below her own mother's life.  The strong bonds between grandparents and grandchildren in the novel, led to talk about grandparent-hood. Loosely remembered:   It's like being in love!  It's what makes  growing old  bearable.

Several members talked about leaving a diary or other writing behind for grandchildren so that they could know how we saw them...how we felt about them...how they changed our lives...

Not a must read for many...but a good discussion.

Friday, March 11, 2011

NPR Follows in Sixth Street Book Group's Tracks!

It seems that NPR has a book group...and the March book is Cutting for Stone!
How cool!



Click on this link to read discussion.



Submitted by Book Group member R.K.

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Feast of The Goat Review

Overall the group felt that the book was an engrossing read constructed in a filmic way. Some comments:  The sections on Trujillo were the best; author  insights into a Shakespearean character were powerful.   Urania was more a symbol of the lasting damage caused by  the Trujillo regime than a real woman; wouldn't a real woman of her intelligence have been able to find a way to peace? The sections on the assassins were gripping, although a number of members couldn't read the torture scenes.  General Pupo Roman was a favorite character because he was so human when he failed to act...even failing to kill himself  to avoid terrible torture.  The author said that writers have a moral obligation to write about politics...and the members felt that the Feast of the Goat was successful because they were moved to think about and discuss political action. Who would they have been in this story...the brave souls who risked everything to hide the assassins, the sycophants that would do anything to retain the chief's favor, victim or victimizer or just passively blind to evil? Obvious connections between other historic dictators were made including Egypt's Mubarak. We wondered briefly why dictators aren't benevolent.  Two members talked about work situations that mirrored the relationship of the Benefactor and his counselors.   One member said that reading and reflecting on good  literature prepares people to make brave and difficult decisions.

More to read by Vargas Llosa:
Author feels that War at the End of the World is his most accomplished novel.  Critic Harold Bloom,  includes the novel in what he calls the "Western Canon."



Sunday, January 23, 2011

R., the Book's Sponsor, Comments on City of Thieves


I'm not really interested in Blogging myself, but I have no objection to your
putting one up about our book group. I did check it out, however, just because I had sponsored the last book, so I felt more of an obligation. I was really more interested in letting YOU know what happened at the meeting. The blog (and by extension--you) did not really capture the jist of the evening. Even though the book itself was considered a 'lightweight' read (even though enjoyable)--it was a foil for an interesting discussion about the Russian people in general and the
Russian people in this specific situation (the Leningrad siege). The author
researched this very carefully and all of the characters and situations were
based on his findings. Benioff had read many diaries of the survivors of this war--and so got a lot of first-hand information. 

City of Thieves...


Sick with the stomach THING attacking Brooklynites...extreme stomach emptying...lucky to have a rather mild version...but alas missed Book Group meeting.
L. sent this summary:  "People thought book was good but it was an adventure story."  In the word BUT lies the discussion...Can an adventure story be literature?  Hmmm.  Huck Finn?  Odyssey?  Perhaps someone will flesh out this discussion to make clear what else made this less than a MUST READ...I'll post any  new comments I receive.