Total Pageviews

Wednesday, February 16, 2011

Feast of The Goat Review

Overall the group felt that the book was an engrossing read constructed in a filmic way. Some comments:  The sections on Trujillo were the best; author  insights into a Shakespearean character were powerful.   Urania was more a symbol of the lasting damage caused by  the Trujillo regime than a real woman; wouldn't a real woman of her intelligence have been able to find a way to peace? The sections on the assassins were gripping, although a number of members couldn't read the torture scenes.  General Pupo Roman was a favorite character because he was so human when he failed to act...even failing to kill himself  to avoid terrible torture.  The author said that writers have a moral obligation to write about politics...and the members felt that the Feast of the Goat was successful because they were moved to think about and discuss political action. Who would they have been in this story...the brave souls who risked everything to hide the assassins, the sycophants that would do anything to retain the chief's favor, victim or victimizer or just passively blind to evil? Obvious connections between other historic dictators were made including Egypt's Mubarak. We wondered briefly why dictators aren't benevolent.  Two members talked about work situations that mirrored the relationship of the Benefactor and his counselors.   One member said that reading and reflecting on good  literature prepares people to make brave and difficult decisions.

More to read by Vargas Llosa:
Author feels that War at the End of the World is his most accomplished novel.  Critic Harold Bloom,  includes the novel in what he calls the "Western Canon."



Sunday, January 23, 2011

R., the Book's Sponsor, Comments on City of Thieves


I'm not really interested in Blogging myself, but I have no objection to your
putting one up about our book group. I did check it out, however, just because I had sponsored the last book, so I felt more of an obligation. I was really more interested in letting YOU know what happened at the meeting. The blog (and by extension--you) did not really capture the jist of the evening. Even though the book itself was considered a 'lightweight' read (even though enjoyable)--it was a foil for an interesting discussion about the Russian people in general and the
Russian people in this specific situation (the Leningrad siege). The author
researched this very carefully and all of the characters and situations were
based on his findings. Benioff had read many diaries of the survivors of this war--and so got a lot of first-hand information. 

City of Thieves...


Sick with the stomach THING attacking Brooklynites...extreme stomach emptying...lucky to have a rather mild version...but alas missed Book Group meeting.
L. sent this summary:  "People thought book was good but it was an adventure story."  In the word BUT lies the discussion...Can an adventure story be literature?  Hmmm.  Huck Finn?  Odyssey?  Perhaps someone will flesh out this discussion to make clear what else made this less than a MUST READ...I'll post any  new comments I receive.  

Tuesday, December 21, 2010

To E or not to E?

That is the question on the minds of many Sixth Street Book Group Members...

Here is what Consumer Reports said...

Named Amazon Kindle 3G & Wi-Fi  the best choice for use every where.
Barnes & Noble Nook 3G & Wi-Fi  is a "step-behind" in almost all respects....

Sony is coming out with a new reader that hasn't been reviewed yet.

Sunday, December 19, 2010

Sixth Street Book Club Rules

1. First meeting in September we select 9 titles to be read that year.
2. In order for a book to be considered, it has to be recommended by a member who has read it.( If the book is selected by the group, this member becomes a sponsor.  The sponsor presents an author bio and comments about the book.)
3. The book has to be available in paper back.
4. Each member has 7 votes.
5. The nine books with the highest number of votes are selected.
6. The last meeting of the year is held in June. During that meeting members talk about books they are planning to read on their "vacation" from book group.
7. We try hard to adhere to one voice at a time!